impan seminar:

working group in applications of set theory





No more talks this semester




Previous talks this semester:



19.12.2023, Tuesday 3pm, room 403

Damian Sobota (Kurt Gödel Research Center)

Title: On convergence of finitely supported measures and filters on ℕ.

Abstract: For a free filter F on ℕ we write NF=ℕ∪{F} and endow this space with the standard topology: points of ℕ are isolated and the neighborhoods of F are all sets of the form A∪{F} for A in F. Spaces NF can be considered as the simplest non-discrete Tychonoff spaces. During the talk we will investigate for which filters F the spaces NF carry sequences (μn)n∈ℕ of finitely supported signed measures with norm 1 and such that μn(f) converges to 0 for every real-valued bounded continuous f on N_F. We show, among others, that this is the case, e.g., if and only if the dual ideal F* is Katetov below the ideal of all sets of asymptotic density zero. We present some applications to Banach spaces of the form C(K). (Joint work with Witold Marciszewski.)


12.12.2023, Tuesday 3pm, room 403

Piotr Koszmider (IM PAN)

Title: Combinatorial set theory in noncommutative applications. Continuation.


5.12.2023, Tuesday 3pm, room 403

Piotr Koszmider (IM PAN)

Title: Combinatorial set theory in noncommutative applications. Continuation.


28.11.2023, Tuesday 3pm, room 403

Piotr Koszmider (IM PAN)

Title: Combinatorial set theory in noncommutative applications. Continuation.


7.11.2023, Tuesday 3pm, room 403

Piotr Koszmider (IM PAN)

Title: Combinatorial set theory in noncommutative applications.

Abstract: In this series of talks we plan to discuss the revelation of combinatorial set-theoretic phenomena in the noncommutative mathematics. This will include introducing and motivating and checking the details of the very basics of this theory (we assume no knowledge of operator algebras or C*-algebras from the participants). We will attempt to focus on concrete combinatorial issues (and not on general algebraic theory) like the passage from ultrafilters to quantum filters, from Boolean algebras and nonmetrizable compact totally disconnected set-theoretic topology to real rank zero and AF nonseparable C*-algebras or the impact of additional set-theoretic axioms.

Like in Boolean algebras, general topology and measure theory in the classical period one could see in C*-algebras (aka operator algebras) one of the modern central notions where the set-theoretic methods can make difference. The following two texts are characteristic of such an approach and will be exploited during the talks: (1) I. Farah, E. Wofsey, Set theory and operator algebras. In Cummings, James (ed.) et al., Appalachian set theory 2006--2012. London Mathematical Society Lecture Note Series 406, 63--119 (2013). (2) I. Farah, Combinatorial set theory of C*-algebras. Springer Monographs in Mathematics. (2019);


24.10.2023, Tuesday 3pm, room 403

Zdeněk Silber (IM PAN)

Title: The Johnson-Lindenstrauss space and property (E). Continuation



17.10.2023, Tuesday 3pm, room 403

Zdeněk Silber (IM PAN)

Title: The Johnson-Lindenstrauss space and property (E).

Abstract: "The Johnson-Lindenstrauss space defined over an uncountable almost disjoint family A is the Banach space JL(A) which has been used to provide many counterexamples in Banach space theory. In the talk, we indroduce the construction of JL(A) and show some of its properties, with special focus on the properties (E) and (E'), which are convex variants of having weak* Frechet-Urysohn dual ball and weak* sequential dual ball respectively.

Specifically, we show that if A is maximal then the dual ball of JL(A) is never Frechet-Uryshon in the weak* topology. On the other hand, for any almost disjoint family A, the dual ball of JL(A) has weak* sequential dual ball (and hence JL(A) has property (E')). The situation with property (E) is more complicated, as it depends on other properties of the almost disjoint family A then just its maximality.

We show a result of Avilés, Martínez-Cervantes and Rodríguez that, under CH, there are two maximal almost disjoint families A and B, such that JL(A) does have property (E) and JL(B) does not. This gives us a consistent example, that none of the implications "weak* FU dual ball" implies (E) implies (E') can be reversed."



10.10.2023, Tuesday 3pm, room 403

Jesús Castillo (Universidad de Extremadura)

Title: Words and the twisting of C(K)-spaces.

Abstract: "Does a Banach space know if it is separable?"







Talks in the second semester of 2022-23.

Talks in the first semester of 2022-23.

Talks in the second semester of 2021-22.

Talks in the first semester of 2021-22.

Talks in the second semester of 2020-21.

Talks in the first semester of 2020-21.

Talks in the second semester of 2019-20.

Talks in the first semester of 2019-20.

Talks in the second semester of 2018-19.

Talks in the first semester of 2018-19.

Talks in the second semester of 2017-18.

Talks in the first semester of 2017-18.

Talks in the second semester of 2016-17.

Talks in the first semester of 2016-17.

Talks in the second semester of 2015-16.

Talks in the first semester of 2015-16.

Talks in the second semester of 2014-15.

Talks in the first semester of 2014-15.

Talks in the second semester of 2013-14.

Talks in the first semester of 2013-14.

Talks in the second semester of 2012-13.

Talks in the first semester of 2012-13.

Talks in the second semester of 2011-12.

Talks in the first semester of 2011-12.

Time and place: Tuesdays 15.00-16.45 pm, room 403, Śniadeckich 8




The scope of the seminar: Set-theoretic combinatorial and topological methods in diverse fields of mathematics, with a special emphasis on abstract analysis like Banach spaces, Banach algebras, C*-algebras, Here we include both the developing of such methods as forcing, descriptive set theory, Ramsey theory as well as their concrete applications in the fields mentioned above.

Working group style: We will make efforts so that this seminar has more a working character rather than the presentation style. This means that we encourage long digressions, discussions, background preparations and participation of everyone. We would like to immerse ourselves into the details of the mathematical arguments studied. Also the talks are usualy devoted to research in progress or fascinating results leading to some project not yet resolved. While ready final results could be presented at other seminars at IM PAN or UW.

Participants this semester so far:

  • Tomasz Cieśla (MIM UW)
  • Damian Głodkowski (PH.D. student UW/IMPAN)
  • Piotr Koszmider (IM PAN)
  • Kacper Kucharski (PH. D. student UW)
  • Maciej Malicki (IM PAN)
  • Kamil Ryduchowski (PH. D. student UW/IMPAN)
  • Zdeněk Silber (IM PAN)
  • Agnieszka Widz (PH.D. student Lodz UT)
  • Krzysztof Zakrzewski (PH.D. student UW)
Forthcoming talks :

  • The plan is to resume the seminar at the begining of the spring semester 2024.